Friday, April 13, 2018

The Shame Behind the Classroom Door: Misconceptions of Illiteracy

By Sydney Cheuvront

Illiteracy in both children and adults is a silenced issue in this country.

In fact, the U.S. Department of Education found that the literacy rate in the country is no better than it was 10 years ago.

And in many states, over half of fourth-graders are not at a proficient reading level, according to the Annie E. Casey Foundation.


But not many people are talking about it.

And when they are, many myths, misconceptions and stereotypes are employed.

Here are four common misconceptions surrounding illiteracy.

If a child cannot read or write, his or her parents must be poor.

This is not true.

Many illiterate students' home lives may be a factor, but socioeconomic status and/or parent's literacy levels are not always to blame.

Kiri Chaboud, an intern for Ready for School, Ready for Life, says that while poverty may be a factor, that does not matter when it comes to a child's reading.

"While poverty plays a large role in limiting certain resources such as childcare, education and access to learning tools, a lot of literacy development starts with simple communication in the home," Chaboud said.

She says parents just need to talk to their children more because talking leads to word association and vocabulary skills.

"No matter the socioeconomic status, if a parent is able to surround their child with a steady flow of conversation, this can develop a strong basis for future literacy skills," Chaboud said.

Kaitlyn Reaves, a first-grade student teacher in Maryland, agrees, saying that there are no economic boundaries to learning and literacy, just social ones.

"A family showing interest in a child's school work will directly increase the student's success in school," Reaves said.  "If a family does not provide a child with the foundations of learning to read, a child will enter kindergarten farther behind a student whose family has invested time in their learning."

These foundations of learning to read include talking to kids daily, reading to them and working on learning the alphabet and letter sounds.

No matter what a parent or family's socioeconomic status is if they take the time to talk and read to their child, literacy is right ahead.


They're never going to do well in school if they can't read by ____ age or at a certain rate or speed.

While many people acknowledge that being different is great and that the world would be boring if we were all the same, somehow that message becomes skewed in school.

We expect all students to be able to read the same thing and be on the same skill level by a certain age.

Chaboud recognizes these disparities and how they help form this myth.

"People often believe that strong literacy skills are tied to the speed that one can read or write," Chaboud said.  "This is a huge misconception and a lot of this is due to the manner in which schools are required to or go about testing literacy."

These tests can include seeing how many words a child can read in a 60-second time span.

"Literacy skills come from so much more than speed," Chaboud said.  "It's the ability to question, infer, read with voice and fluency and think critically and creatively."

Reaves also points out how reading is not the end-all, be-all of literacy.

"It is important to remember that reading is only one aspect of language acquisition," Reaves said.  "Reading is often the last step of language acquisition in a child, preceded by comprehending verbal language, phonemic awareness and phonological awareness."

Every child is different and learns at his or her own pace.  Because of this standardization, this sentiment has been lost.


They must be stupid or lazy if they are illiterate.

Literacy does not equal intelligence.

Chaboud sees this all the time.

"While literacy aids multiple dimensions of learning, it does not mean that these people are incapable of learning or holding other skill sets," Chaboud said.  "And often these people desire the ability to read and write."

This desire also debunks the assumption that kids and adults that cannot read are simply lazy.

Reaves has many students who are not native English speakers.  They struggle to read and write in English and translate in their heads.  But the important this is that they do try.

"My class contains 11 students out of 25 who speak English as their second language," Reaves said.  "However, these students have brilliant minds and work twice as hard as an only English-speaking student."

She says that at this age, students minds are open to learning all new things and maintaining such information.  So even though these students may not have English down perfectly, their brains are working hard and taking in everything.

"Students at this age have a higher capacity to learn a second language than adults or older students," Reaves said.  "In this way, students who are 'illiterate' are actually using more brain power than the average English-only student."

Learning disabilities also play a huge role in when children learn how to read.  Katherine Donnelly studied early childhood education and says people do not realize the tremendous impact.

"People get really concerned when they see their very young children writing letters and numbers backward," Donnelly said.  "But dyslexia can't really be diagnosed until age seven."

Reaves sees this in her student teaching and acknowledges that it does not mean the child is not smart.

"Dyslexia does not cause an individual to be unable to read, or to be any less smart than another student," Reaves said.  "This simply means the student will need more accommodations, patience and work in order to read on grade level."

It is important to recognize how each student learns and work towards their strengths, instead of using the same assessment on every child.  Instead of utilizing skills they have, it points out weaknesses leading to harmful misconceptions.


Learning to read in one's native language will make it harder to read and write in English.

Many parents believe that teaching their children their native language will not allow them to be on the same track as an English-only student or that it will confuse them.

It all goes back to parents talking to and interacting with their children.  If a child gets that interaction, it aids in developing all of the literacy skills that come before fully reading and writing.

Parents believe that sticking their child in front of a television will help them learn English and be successful in school, but the crucial interaction is missing.

Reaves has experienced this in her current student-teaching position and past internship.  She found ways to use the students' native language and relate it to English.

"By showing children how their home language relates to English in a variety of ways, the child can feel confident in their use of their home language and English," Reaves said.

Reaves would encourage her students to say words and phrases in both English and Spanish so that they could practice connecting the two languages.

"The most important thing we're taught is to value and respect their home language because it is part of their identity and they should never feel ashamed of it," Reaves said.


Moving Forward

People do not realize the immense impact these misconceptions can have on children learning to read and write.

Source: Kaitlyn Reaves
Young children are at a crucial social and emotional state and crave approval and attention.  Perpetuating these misconceptions onto children could stunt their learning and affect them for the rest of their lives.

Looking forward, Chaboud wants people to know that learning never stops and does not discriminate.

"Everyone is capable of learning; it is never too late to develop these skills," Chaboud said.  "You don't need the highest quality education to be literate, use what's around you and practice every day."


She has one last thing for everyone to remember: "Being illiterate means nothing unless you let it."



                 

Related Stories:

6 Myths About Kindergarten Literacy Instruction
Seven Myths About Literacy in the U.S.
Leveled Reading: The Making of a Literacy Myth

Thursday, March 29, 2018

Protect our Kids, Protect our Teachers... Through All Grades

By Sydney Cheuvront



Seventeen deadly school shootings in 2018.

Great Mills, Maryland has been added to the list of shootings that seems never-ending.

But what happens after the gunfire?  How can educators take back their classroom?

These questions surround elementary and high school teachers and even college professors.

Mindy Brame, Liz McSorley and Kristina Bell all wonder about these questions.  They worry about the future in their classrooms and for their students.  From violence with younger students to receiving threats, the fear of being the next shooting is always in the back of their minds.

And it's not easy having to explain what to do if it ever happened or how to move forward.


Violence from Students in Elementary School

Mindy Brame is a second-grade teacher at Oak Ridge Elementary in High Point, North Carolina.  She says that she has to assure her students that they are safe during times of lockdowns.

Source: Campus Safety Magazine
"We were told just to reiterate to the students that they are safe and that school is a safe place," Brame said. "We were told just to try to make them feel like we've got everything under control."

One response from a student shocked Brame.

"One student said that her mom was going to send in a door stopper for her book bag," Brame said.

Many parents have been giving their children door stoppers to protect them.  The stopper can still keep the door closed even if the lock is compromised.  This can buy students, teachers and police more time if a shooting were to occur.


But the door stopper would do very little if the threat came from inside the classroom.

Brame described a student who threatened her and his classmates.  She feared the student could harm someone.

"It was a student who bragged that he was going to steal the souls from students and that he was a demon," Brame said. "He did threaten to shoot me, the students and the assistant principal."

This student was never suspended and it never went on the school report.  Teachers were told it was because of the negative publicity the school would have received.  

Source: Campus Safety Magazine
"That happens a lot," Brame said.  "However, the student has not gotten help and continues to be a concern.  Although now, he is just heavily medicated."

Brame believes that many students' issues, like the one she discusses, stem from multiple avenues.

Children are exposed to adult subject matter too early through the Internet and video games and are not properly monitored.  She also feels that they are taught to be competitive with one another at an early age through standardized testing.  The focus of school has shifted from students to numbers.

"I do have a theory that we are not meeting the emotional needs of our children anymore," Brame said.

Threats in High School

Moving on to high school should be an exciting time in a student's life, but with the current state of affairs, it could end the student's life.

Hearing about school shootings in another state scares teachers and students around the nation.  But when it could happen in our own backyard.

Liz McSorley is a special education student teacher at Ledford High School in Thomasville, North Carolina.

Two days after the Parkland shooting, her school received a threat.

An unknown student called in the night before and threatened to shoot up the school the next day.  McSorley was shocked to walk into the school and hear the news.

"The kids were worried and were pulled out [of school] because parents were concerned," McSorley said.

McSorley's students had many questions the next day.  She felt it was her duty to address them.

"It's very important to discuss. It takes time out of a lesson [but] it's their life," McSorley said.

While this event had an impact on the students, it had an even bigger one on McSorley.  She now looks at her future profession in a different light, noting new safety implications she has to keep in mind.  She says she is definitely more scared to teach when she is the head of the classroom.

"I've been thinking about how I would set up my future classroom to include furniture that would be easy to move, but big enough for students to hide behind and not get injured," McSorley said.  "It made me more scared because I'm not even in my first year of teaching and I've already experienced a school threat."

McSorley also worries about the students she would care for.  According to a study from Penn State University, many students experience post-traumatic stress disorder, anxiety and burnout after a school shooting.  McSorley has added challenges.

"Because I'd be teaching special needs students, it would be even more of a challenge to try to ease their emotions," McSorley said.

Many people overlook how important a teacher's job is and just what it entails.  Now there is a direct safety risk, something McSorley does not take lightly.

"[The threat] just made me realize that by becoming a teacher, I just sort of signed up to put my life second to my students' safety," McSorley said.  "That is definitely not what I imagined I would have to ever do, but school violence is becoming more of a problem, unfortunately."

McSorley is correct.  School shootings are becoming too common, but she, like many others, does not know a clear solution.  But she offers some ways schools could improve.

"I think schools should be required to teach students and teachers on a regular basis what to do, where to hide and where to move desks in case there is a shooting," McSorley said.  "More police officers or school resource officers trained in stopping a shooter should be required in every school and they should be trained to respond to that type of situation."

Until some changes are put into place, McSorley, along with other teachers and student teachers, is left to wonder what high school could be next in the headlines.



What Happens in College?

When students graduate from high school and move on to college the chance of a school shooting does not rest.

Some of the deadliest school shootings have occurred on college campuses, according to Dayton Daily News.

 One of the most notable shootings happened only a little over a decade ago.

The shooting at Virginia Tech in April of 2007 rocked the nation.  No one had seen such destruction and death on a college campus in decades.  Thirty-two people were killed and dozens were wounded.  

However, the school was fined by the U.S. Department of Education after not properly alerting students when shots first rang out.

Now many colleges across the nation are preparing plans in case of an active shooter.

High Point University professor Kristina Bell recalls a faculty meeting in 2015 with a video detailing what professors and students should do in the case of a shooting.

"It talked about how our first step should be to run away to safety if we can," Bell said.  "If we can't run, we should hide and make it look like it's an empty room, and if that doesn't work, we should fight."

She told her students this and was met with mixed reactions.

"They kind of looked at me.  Some were wide-eyed, others nodded," Bell said.  "They didn't respond verbally."

Many students and professors worry that at a campus like HPU they are more susceptible to being in danger during a school shooting.  The school features designs that focus more on aesthetics than safety.  It would not protect students in the event of an active shooter.  From the open spaces to glass classrooms, many students and professors could be sitting ducks.
The HPU Game Lab where Bell often teaches

"Sometimes I think about how the Game Lab is all glass, and I get nervous," Bell said.  "Or that all of our doors have windows.  I have certainly thought about the best way to hide or respond in all of the classrooms I teach."

While college campuses are more spacious, classrooms like the one Bell described can be extremely dangerous in the event of a school shooting.

And on top of taking time away from teaching, Bell also worries about when she has to send her son to school.  She says that many kindergarten classes treat active shooter drills as a game, where the child should stay quiet when he or she hears an alarm, in order for younger kids to understand what to do in a situation.

"People are discussing which one is better for a four or five-year-old, which is crazy to have to think about," Bell said.

...

While different schools handle shootings differently, everything is connected.

The student teacher worries about when she has her own classroom.  The second-grade teacher worries about moving forward.  The professor worries about her easily targetable classroom and then when her child will begin school.


With no clear solution in sight, these three women's anxieties are warranted.  



Related Stories

  • https://www.npr.org/2018/02/22/588069918/how-school-shootings-have-changed-the-teaching-profession
  • https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2018/02/teaching-while-afraid/553931/







Monday, March 12, 2018

Pencils, Book Bags and Guns? The Newest National Debate


Columbine.  Virginia Tech.  Sandy Hook.

These names bring terror into the public's minds and send shivers down their spines.  The newest name added to this list is Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School.

This recent school shooting has sparked one of the hottest debates in the media: To arm or not to arm teachers.

According to a USA Today article, there have been 22 school shootings where more than two people were killed since 1990.  Seventeen people died in the Florida shooting.

Many people took to social media to share their opinion on whether or not allowing schoolteachers to carry firearms is a beneficial idea.

President Donald Trump tweeted about how teachers with guns could keep students safe before police could arrive at the scene.

This stance differs from a previous tweet Donald Trump posted during the election season.

However, some people agree with the presidents current stance. They think arming teachers is the only way to prevent more deadly school shootings and that students safety is the schools responsibility.  



One person used the saying "The only way to stop a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun," from NRA Executive Vice President Wayne Lapierre after the Sandy Hook shooting. 

Other social media users even made Facebook pages, like the one below, to comment on arming teachers.
 

This has sparked outrage from some parents and social media users saying teachers carrying guns in school would only create more problems from race-based shootings to accidental violence.

  


One Twitter user expressed her anger over the president's comments and responded to one of President Trump's tweets.

Numerous social media users pointed out that what teachers lacked in the classroom were not guns but school supplies for their students.  survey from Scholastic revealed teachers spend around $500 of their own money on school supplies every year.  Teachers and principals in high-poverty schools spend even more.



 This issue has even expanded to a movement, created by two educators, with the hashtag #ArmMeWith.  Schoolteachers have been sharing what their classrooms truly need, and it is not guns.  The requests range from books to funding to social and emotional support for students.  The teachers involved in the campaign say they know what is best for their students and what they need.




Joshua Grubbs, a psychology professor at Bowling Green State University and a gun owner, posted a video detailing why teachers and professors should not carry guns.  Grubbs says an armed teacher could be mistaken for a suspect during a school shooting.

One Facebook user made an argument in support of a less-expensive and safer alternative to guns: a fire extinguisher.
 
 
While this is a serious issue, many Twitter users took a comical approach to express their opinions on whether or not to arm teacher.  They alluded to popular television shows and movies and shared personal experiences from the classroom.





The debate on arming teachers grew even more heated after a high school teacher in Georgia opened fire on Feb. 28.  Jesse Randal Davidson barricaded himself in his classroom at Dalton High School and shot a handgun.

Davidson has a history of mental illness and even had three rifles removed from his home after setting his family's car ablaze two years ago.  

Students at the school took to Twitter to express their dismay and share experiences from that day, even tweeting directly at the NRA.




This complicated issue is still in the headlines due to the many student activists from Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School and now Dalton High School.  Some states have already moved in the direction of banning guns in the classroom, while others have struck such legislation down.

As of right now, the question "To arm or not to arm?" goes unanswered.